John O’Leary welcomes cultural theologian and author Paul Anleitner to discuss why the stories we embrace matter, how our culture is rediscovering hope after cynicism, and what it means to build a life rooted in truth, purpose, and authentic community.
Paul Anleitner is a cultural theologian, author of Based on a True Story, and President & CEO of Goodmakers, where he helps people understand how culture and the stories we believe shape our search for meaning. Drawing from theology, philosophy, and science, Paul has become a leading voice on navigating today’s cultural shifts with hope, wisdom, and purpose.
Today, Paul shares how the stories we embrace influence the way we see ourselves and the world around us, why our culture is moving beyond cynicism and endless deconstruction, and what it looks like to rebuild lives rooted in meaning, truth, and authentic community. Along the way, he explains why so many people feel spiritually and emotionally adrift, how to recognize the stories stealing our hope, and where we can begin finding better ones.
My friends, if you’ve ever wondered why so many people feel disconnected or found yourself longing for more purpose, hope, and belonging, this conversation is for you. You’ll leave reminded that the foundation is firm, the headwinds may be real, but the best is yet to come.
Subscribe & listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora, iHeartRadio or listen here:
Or click here to watch the full conversation on YouTube!
- “Why am I here? What’s the point?” Every person is searching for meaning and how the stories we believe shape the lives we live.
- Paul defines deconstruction as viewing the past through a lens of suspicion. While there is a place for reform, he argues that endlessly tearing things down without rebuilding leaves us searching for purpose.
- “We can’t just carry a sledgehammer around.” Our culture is shifting from deconstruction toward reconstruction, rebuilding lives rooted in hope, meaning, and community.
- We all long for meaning, which rests on three essential pillars: coherence (making sense of the world), purpose (knowing where life is headed), and significance (believing our lives matter).
- Paul contrasts cynicism with wisdom, explaining that cynicism walls us off from possibility while wisdom helps us see reality through the lens of truth, goodness, and beauty.
- “Pay attention to the wholesome. Pay attention to what makes you feel whole.” Paul shares why noticing what brings genuine wholeness (not just temporary happiness) can guide us toward a more meaningful life.
- Authentic community, trust, and shared purpose often resonate more deeply than success, achievement, or endless self-discovery.
- Mean World Syndrome: the tendency for constant exposure to negative stories to distort our perception of reality, and why the stories we consume profoundly influence the future we believe is possible.
- Choosing stories rooted in hope, truth, and possibility allows us to become active participants in cultural renewal rather than passive observers of decline.
- Get a copy of Paul Anleitner’s book Based on a True Story here.
Did you enjoy today’s episode?
You’ll love my conversation with Gregg Easterbrook. As a New York Times bestselling author, Gregg shares a compelling, fact-based case that despite what the headlines often tell us, this is actually the best time in human history. He explains why we’re wired to notice the negative, how the media can distort our perspective, and why choosing optimism is one of the wisest decisions we can make. It’s a conversation that will encourage you, challenge your assumptions, and remind you that while the headwinds may be real, our foundation is firm… and the best is truly yet to come. Listen to Gregg Easterbrook on ep. 121 now.
***
About our sponsor: Keeley Companies wholeheartedly believes that if you get the people right -the results will follow. They set themselves apart with a forward-thinking culture that empowers their people and fosters loyal partnerships. Keeley Companies are a proud sponsor, partner, and super fan of the Live Inspired Podcast. Learn more about Keeley Companies.
PAUL ANLEITNER'S LIVE INSPIRED 7
- Q. What is the best book you’ve ever read?
A. The Bible and Provocations by Søren Kierkegaard. - Q. What is a characteristic or trait that you possessed as a child that you wish you still exhibited today?
A. Resilience. - Q. Your house is on fire, all living things and people are out. You have the opportunity to run in and grab one item. What would it be?
A. If my wife and kids are out, maybe I'd grab some old comic books. - Q. You are sitting on a bench overlooking a gorgeous beach. You have the opportunity to have a long conversation with anyone living or dead. Who would it be?
A. C.S. Lewis. - Q. What is the best advice you’ve ever received?
A. "And" is freedom. "Or" is tyranny. - Q. What advice would you give your 20-year-old self?
A. Be less cynical and be more open to wisdom that you do not have right now. Second, there is something sacred in the ordinary and mundane. - Q. It’s been said that all great people can have their lives summed up in one sentence. How do you want yours to read?
A. He gave it his best.
